Article Title

The U. S. Supreme Court and its Decisions.

Authors

Newspaper Title

Ohio State Journal

Publication Date

3-14-1857

Publication Place

Columbus,Ohio

Event Topic

Dred Scott

Political Party

Republican

Region

free state

Quote

The United States Supreme Court consists of nine judges.

Document Type

Article (Journal or Newsletter)

Full Text Transcription

The United States Supreme Court consists of of nine judges. The following five, or a majority of one, adopt the decision in the Dred Scott case and its accompanying doctrines, which were read on Friday by Chief Justice Taney:--

Roger B. Taney ofMaryland.John A. Campbell of Alabama.John Catron of Tennessee.James H. Wayne of Georgia.Peter V. Daniel of Virginia

These are all the judges who reside in the slave states. They represent and avow boldly the new opinions of their section, that slavery is a national institution, the equal of freedom, and that all prohibition of it in the territories, either by Congress or the people, is unconstitutional. The two following judges dodge the general slavery issues, and the question of the constitutionality of the Missouri Compromise, but come to the same conclusion with the majority, as to Dred Scott, i. e., that he and his family are slaves, by holding that it depended on the law of Missouri, and that declaring them slaves, they sustain it:--

Samuel Nelson of New York.Robert C. Grier of Pennsylvania.

These men are northern democrats. Their course is consistent with the tribe of doughfaces whom they represent. There remain two judges who, alone, have manfully upheld the faith of the nation, the practice of the past, and the universal sentiment still of the North:--

John McLean of Ohio.Benjamin R. Curtis ofMassachusetts

These gentlemen were old whigs, and eminent conservatives.

Edited/Proofed by

Entered by Lloyd Benson. Proofed by Katie DeLong

Identifier

ohsjds570314a

Rights

This item is in the public domain, and can be used by anyone without restriction.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

 
COinS
 

The U. S. Supreme Court and its Decisions.

The United States Supreme Court consists of nine judges.